Connect with us

Subscribe

Americas

Real Pay Data Show Trump’s ‘Blue-Collar Boom’ is More of a Bust for U.S. Workers, in 3 Charts

The real, inflation-adjusted data show most U.S. workers have not benefited from the growing economy.

Donald Trump speaks at the Conservative Political Action Conference in National Harbor, Maryland in 2011. (Image Credit: Gage Skidmore/Flickr)
Donald Trump speaks at the Conservative Political Action Conference in National Harbor, Maryland in 2011. (Image Credit: Gage Skidmore/Flickr)

If you thought workers’ hourly pay was finally rising, think again.

At first glance, the latest data – which came out on Feb. 7 – look pretty good. They show nominal hourly earnings rose 3.1% in January from a year earlier.

But the operative word here is nominal, which means not adjusted for changes in the cost of living. Once you factor in inflation, the picture changes drastically. And far from representing a “blue-collar boom” – as the president put it in his State of the Union address – the real, inflation-adjusted data show most U.S. workers have not benefited from the growing economy.

As an economist who studies wage data, I think it’s paramount that we take a step back and look at what the data really show.

The Effect of Inflation and Fringes

The Bureau of Labor Statistics comes out with two sets of data on wages.

Business journalists and financial markets tend to focus on the monthly data. These figures are only reported in nominal or current terms because the inflation data doesn’t come out until later.

A more complete set of wage and pay data is reported quarterly. The latest release came out in December for the third quarter. These figures are not only adjusted for inflation but also include fringe benefits, which account for just under a third of total compensation.

At first blush, it makes sense to focus primarily on the first set. Newer data is, well, newer, and market participants and companies prefer the latest information when making decisions about investments, hiring and so on.

But the effect of inflation means that the same US$1 bill buys less stuff over time as prices increase.

From December 2016 to September 2019, nominal wages rose 6.79% from $22.83 to $24.38. But after factoring in inflation, average wages barely budged, climbing just 0.42% in the period.

Incorporating fringe benefits into the picture adds another wrinkle.

The inflation-adjusted or real value of fringe benefits, which include compensation that comes in the form of health insurance, retirement, and bonuses, declined 1.7% in the three-year period.

Altogether, that means total real compensation slipped 0.22% from the end of 2016 to September 2019.

Of course, workers in different sectors have fared differently. The Trump administration has singled out manufacturing workers – who it says are the main beneficiaries of its trade war and other policies intended to support the sector – as having benefited from a “blue-collar boom” in wages.

The nominal data for manufacturing workers hardly support a boom but they do show an increase of 2.22% since Donald Trump took office.

The adjusted data, however, make it look more like a bust, with wages plunging 3.88% in the period. And, again, the situation is worse when we add in fringe benefits, which brings the decline to 4.33%.

So next time you read a story about a rise in pay, try to see if it reports the wage data in nominal or real terms and if it includes fringe benefits too. If it’s only nominal wages, the numbers may mean a lot less than they seem.

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

By submitting your info, you agree to our terms of use.

Written By

David Salkever is professor emeritus of public policy at the University of Maryland, Baltimore County.

Preventing a quagmire in Ukraine Preventing a quagmire in Ukraine

Preventing a Ukraine War Quagmire: Lessons from Iraq

Europe

What the Discord leaks say about India and Pakistan What the Discord leaks say about India and Pakistan

The Discord Leaks Hit India and Pakistan

South Asia

U.S.-South Korea nuclear deal U.S.-South Korea nuclear deal

Inside the U.S.-South Korea Nuclear Weapons Deal

Asia

hawaii california gas prices most expensive in us hawaii california gas prices most expensive in us

Here’s Where Gas is the Most Expensive in the U.S.

Americas

China attacks U.S. satellites China attacks U.S. satellites

China May Be Developing Ways to Attack Satellites

Space

Ohio Senator JD Vance defends Tucker Carlson Ohio Senator JD Vance defends Tucker Carlson

J.D. Vance Blasts Pentagon Celebration of Tucker Carlson Firing

Americas

U.S.-China competition over semiconductors U.S.-China competition over semiconductors

U.S. Semiconductor Export Controls Intensify Global Tech Competition

Americas

Visit of South Korea President Yoon Suk Yeol Visit of South Korea President Yoon Suk Yeol

South Korea President Heads to Washington as Regional Threats Grow

Asia

NEWSLETTER

By submitting your information, you are agreeing to our terms of use.

Connect
Subscribe to Our Newsletter

By submitting your info, you agree to our terms of use.