Connect with us

Subscribe

South Asia

Muted Response From Washington on New Delhi’s Annexation of Kashmir

Major media outlets are criticizing India’s crackdown on the Muslim-majority region of Kashmir.

President Donald J. Trump and First Lady Melania Trump greet Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi at the White House on June 27, 2017. (Image Credit: White House)
President Donald J. Trump and First Lady Melania Trump greet Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi at the White House on June 27, 2017. (Image Credit: White House)

On Monday, India effectively annexed the disputed region of Kashmir also claimed by Pakistan. Fearing retaliation from locals, the decision was accompanied by a huge security clampdown, the imposition of a curfew on millions of people, and a communication blackout. Local political leaders, including two pro-India former chief ministers Mehbooba Mufti and Omar Abdullah, have been put under detention.

The introduction of Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Bill by Indian Home Minister Amit Shah in the lower house of parliament on Tuesday garnered severe criticism and opposition from Pakistan. Pakistan has, ever since then, downgraded diplomatic and trade ties with India.

In the United States, the official response was modest, though the move by New Delhi could be seen as a swipe at President Donald Trump, who claimed last month that Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi asked him to mediate between his country and Pakistan on Kashmir.

The State Department issued a statement expressing concern “about reports of detentions” and urging “respect for individual rights and discussion with those in affected communities.” It also called on India and Pakistan to “maintain peace along the Line of Control” that separated Pakistans Azad Jammu and Kashmir region from Indian-controlled Kashmir.

The top U.S. diplomat for South Asia, Alice Wells, also refuted claims made by the Indian news site ThePrint that the Indian government had already informed the U.S government of its decision to change the status of the disputed territory.

Two top Congressional Democrats also released a statement on Tuesday that appeared tougher on Pakistan than India. While Rep. Eliot Engel and Sen. Bob Menendez urged India to “demonstrate for all its citizens the importance of protecting and promoting equal rights, including freedom of assembly, access to information, and equal protection under the law,” they also warned Pakistan against “any retaliatory aggression.” Engel is a member of the House India Caucus, while Menendez is part of the Senate’s corresponding caucus.

While Democrats in Congress failed to mention the arrest of hundreds of political leaders and activists and a curfew imposed on millions in the Muslim-majority region, a more balanced statement was issued by influential Republican Sen. Lindsey Graham, who identified India’s change in Kashmir’s status as potentially destabilizing.

Graham reportedly has the ear of Trump on foreign policy and, according to Pakistani Prime Minister Imran Khan, helped facilitate the White House meeting between the two leaders last month.

While the Trump administration and Congress issued muted responses to India’s crackdown on the Muslim-majority region of Kashmir, major U.S. news outlets strongly criticized New Delhi in editorials this week. The New York Times described Modi’s move as “incendiary” and said that his government’s decision to revoke Kashmir’s special status was “dangerous and wrong.”

Bloomberg Opinion also described India’s scrapping of the nominal autonomy of Kashmir as a “mistake” and challenged New Delhi’s claims that economic development is key to addressing the grievances of Kashmiris. The website pointedly said that Kashmiris feel a “lack of agency,” which is “exacerbated by a suffocating security presence they view as an occupation.”

So while New Delhi has largely escaped rebuke from global capitals, including Washington, major media outlets are highlighting its clampdown on ordinary Kashmiris and their political leaders.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

By submitting your info, you agree to our terms of use.

Written By

Urooj Tarar covers South Asia and pivot states for Globely News. She previously worked for the English-language edition of Daily Pakistan.

Preventing a quagmire in Ukraine Preventing a quagmire in Ukraine

Preventing a Ukraine War Quagmire: Lessons from Iraq

Europe

How climate change is impacting India How climate change is impacting India

Deadly Heat Threatens India’s Progress on Poverty and Inequality

South Asia

What the Discord leaks say about India and Pakistan What the Discord leaks say about India and Pakistan

The Discord Leaks Hit India and Pakistan

South Asia

U.S.-South Korea nuclear deal U.S.-South Korea nuclear deal

Inside the U.S.-South Korea Nuclear Weapons Deal

Asia

Former Indian Navy officers caught spying on Qatar for Israel Former Indian Navy officers caught spying on Qatar for Israel

Qatar Said to Charge Ex-Indian Navy Officers With Spying for Israel

Middle East

hawaii california gas prices most expensive in us hawaii california gas prices most expensive in us

Here’s Where Gas is the Most Expensive in the U.S.

Americas

China attacks U.S. satellites China attacks U.S. satellites

China May Be Developing Ways to Attack Satellites

Space

India overtakes China as the world's most populated country India overtakes China as the world's most populated country

India Passing China As Most Populous Country: Does Size Matter?

South Asia

NEWSLETTER

By submitting your information, you are agreeing to our terms of use.

Connect
Subscribe to Our Newsletter

By submitting your info, you agree to our terms of use.